By Antoinette Bueno
3:00 AM PDT, September 15, 2012
The week in fashion was still all about New York Fashion Week, but which star was the most chic? You decide!
1 / 11
Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion

Getty Images
The week in fashion was still all about New York Fashion Week, but which star was the most chic? You decide!
Stacy Keibler

Getty Images
Are you a Stacy Keibler style fan, or is this hot pink color all wrong with her dark tan?
Jessica Alba

Getty Images
Does Jessica Alba got it going on, or is her fashion sense completely gone?
Tyra Banks

Getty Images
Does Tyra Banks look awesome in a trench coat and a sexy bob, or does she look like a slob?
Elisabeth Moss

Getty Images
Does Elisabeth Moss look great in black and glittery gold, or are you not quite sold?
Olivia Munn

Getty Images
Is Olivia Munn looking cute as a dimple, or is this green dress a little too simple?
Kelly Osbourne

Getty Images
Is Kelly Osbourne showing her fashion flare, or can you not get past her ridiculous hair?
Kristen Wiig

Getty Images
Is Kristen Wiig looking enviably svelte, or could you do without this super-wide belt?
Emma Watson

Getty Images
Is Emma Watson a high-fashion star, or is this one-sleeve ensemble just flat-out bizarre
Julianne Hough

Getty Images
Do you love Julianne Hough's slicked-back 'do, or is it a little too edgy for you?
Lauren Conrad

Getty Images
Is Lauren Conrad always in style, or do you find this floral-print dress vile?