By Antoinette Bueno
3:00 AM PDT, September 8, 2012
The week in fashion was all about film festivals and New York Fashion Week, but which stars stood out as the most chic? You decide!
1 / 11
Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion

Getty Images
The week in fashion was all about film festivals and New York Fashion Week, but which stars stood out as the most chic? You decide!
Selena Gomez

Getty Images
Does Selena Gomez look amazing in a dramatic nude gown, or is this a look that makes you frown?
Vanessa Hudgens

Getty Images
Does Vanessa Hudgens look adorably demure, or does her bad fashion have no cure?
Kristen Stewart
Getty Images
Did Kristen Stewart look amazing with her long locks in a sleek ponytail, or is her highly anticipated post-scandal appearance an epic fail?
Mariah Carey

Getty Images
Does Mariah Carey have a banging post-baby body, or is this gold dress gaudy?
Amy Adams

Getty Images
Does Amy Adams look great in plum, or do you wish she would look less glum?
Sarah Jessica Parker

Getty Images
Is Sarah Jessica Parker well deserving of her fashion-queen label, or does her printed red Oscar de la Renta dress look like it belongs on a picnic table?
Kristin Chenoweth

Getty Images
A look to revere, or a little too severe?
Nicole Richie

Getty Images
Is Nicole Richie best-dressed, or is she showing way too much chest?
Katharine McPhee

Getty Images
Do you love the bold mini dress that Katharine McPhee wore, or is this colorful print a total eyesore?
Kirsten Dunst
Getty Images
Is Kirsten Dunst's slim physique insane, or is this dress a little too plain?