Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion

Is Nicki Minaj a fashion genius, or is she even being serious?!

Is Lily Collins' retro style beautifully old school, or just seriously uncool?

Does Lea Michele look super fine, or are you turned off by her plunging neckline?

Does Kim Kardashian look regal in blue, or is this not the right hue?

Is Jessica Alba's long grey dress adorable, or flat out horrible?

Is Taylor Swift's fashion week choice refreshingly bold, or does it just make her look super-old?

Does Jennifer Garner look cute in pink, or does her pregnant style stink?

When it comes to fashion, does Beyonce always have the magic touch, or is this busy dress just much too much?

Is Paula Abdul dazzling in sequin stripes, or is this dress not your type?

Is the former "Gilmore Girl" looking great in gold, or does her look leave you cold?

The stars clearly shined at New York Fashion Week, but which styles were perfect, and which outfits needed a tweak? From T Swift to Kim K, which dresses were yay, and which ones were nay?